Skip to main content

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Darwin's Angel

978-1-84668-065-6

The problem with books about evolution and theology is that sooner or later they will drag the reader into some kind of dilemma. And it often gets messy. Darwin’s Angel doesn’t disappoint. But it does work from a fascinating premise, that of a direct correspondence style, a “journal-letter”, as the author describes it, aimed entirely at Professor Richard Dawkins, unpicking and reweaving the argument set out in The God Delusion in a one sided but enriching conversation. During our discussions in the group, we wondered what Dawkins’s responses would be, if indeed he has ever read “Darwins Angel”.

Any book tackling the very existence of life is bound to throw up complexities and nuances that can derail and divert when the details become the focus of discussion. Darwin’s Angel manages to avoid most of these heffalump traps by facing them head on. As a student and researcher of evolution I approached the book with enthusiasm and fascination. I have a relationship with Dawkins that extends back to The Selfish Gene, published in the late 1970s. He was and remains one of the world’s greatest explainers of the whole theory. I revere him. So, when I was exploring my emergent Christianity in the early 2000s and I came up against the same man but as a sometime anti-theoligian, I found his approach both challenging and also shallow. John Cornwell’s book helps to rebalance the debate.

Dawkins polarised the “science v religion” stances that became known as “new atheism”, but did this by feeding off the creationist and young earth stances of some bible literalists. Cornwell gives no space to such a debate, preferring through the journal-letter to tackle matters of moral philosophy, theodicy and science in a far more erudite and intellectually rigorous form.

It is a good book: one that bears rereading. It is only slim (164 pages) but shows that in the debate we can find understanding rather than conflict.